Thursday, May 26, 2005
Challenges
Tonight was a good night, right up to the end. Then, things got challenging.
Tonight, McMonk refused to listen to me as a parent, and I didn't know what to do. She and Banana had been feuding, on and off, for the parts of the evening that they had been together. Metaphorical grey thunderheads had been building as we wound down our evening with a bit of TV, brushing teeth, washing up, reading a story. When the story ended in Banana's room.
"Alright, story's over. Time to head down to your room, McMonk." I said lightly.
"Nope, I'm staying here." she replied, looking me right in the eyes.
McMonk refused to leave to let her sister go to sleep by herself. As Banana had been defensive about her stuff and her space all night (and I had stayed out of the referee role so far), I tried to jump in before anger happened on either side.
I saw this as. plain and simple, as a refusal to accept my authority. I knew I could use physical force to get her out of the room, but that isn't (and has never been) my way. Besides, physical force only lasted for so long - a strong will can outlast a parent sitting outside a door, barring you from entering or exiting.
I tried coercion, asking her to please go down to her room. She refused. I tried logic, saying that she and Banana would just be fighting all night. She stated that they wouldn't be fighting and that she'd leave if Banana bothered her too much.
I tried explaining my reasons for asking her to move, saying I didn't want to have to diffuse a fight by siding with Banana and evicting her from Banana's room. I said I was trying to circumvent the fight by having her leave beforehand. She claimed that I had already taken sides with Banana. I denied it, saying I was making the call beforehand. Still, she refused to leave.
Banana spoke up and said, "I don't care if she stays - I just want to sleep."
So, I turned off the light and left the room.
In school, children follow the authority of the teacher to do assignments, even homework, even though they don't want to do it. In sports, the athletes follow the authority of the coaches, doing physically tough activities, even though it is sometimes hard, even painful, to do. In our homes, we follow the requests of our parents, because they are there to teach us lessons, even though those lessons are not always fun ones to learn.
I feel that I've lost my authority over McMonk. This is a sad thing, because without authority, I doubt she'll follow any of the hard lessons that I have for her - therefore, I've lost the ability to teach her effectively. I've noticed this in other areas of her life: her reluctance to do homework and sometimes attend school; her reluctance to be on time or attend swim practice; now, her reluctance and sometimes refusal to do as I ask her. I can see this spiraling downwards, to the point where she'll only do what she wants to do and will get used to shirking any authority.
I know she's intelligent enough to grasp big concepts like this. She and I need to have a serious talk about her disregard for authority. It is a bad path to start down.
Tonight, McMonk refused to listen to me as a parent, and I didn't know what to do. She and Banana had been feuding, on and off, for the parts of the evening that they had been together. Metaphorical grey thunderheads had been building as we wound down our evening with a bit of TV, brushing teeth, washing up, reading a story. When the story ended in Banana's room.
"Alright, story's over. Time to head down to your room, McMonk." I said lightly.
"Nope, I'm staying here." she replied, looking me right in the eyes.
McMonk refused to leave to let her sister go to sleep by herself. As Banana had been defensive about her stuff and her space all night (and I had stayed out of the referee role so far), I tried to jump in before anger happened on either side.
I saw this as. plain and simple, as a refusal to accept my authority. I knew I could use physical force to get her out of the room, but that isn't (and has never been) my way. Besides, physical force only lasted for so long - a strong will can outlast a parent sitting outside a door, barring you from entering or exiting.
I tried coercion, asking her to please go down to her room. She refused. I tried logic, saying that she and Banana would just be fighting all night. She stated that they wouldn't be fighting and that she'd leave if Banana bothered her too much.
I tried explaining my reasons for asking her to move, saying I didn't want to have to diffuse a fight by siding with Banana and evicting her from Banana's room. I said I was trying to circumvent the fight by having her leave beforehand. She claimed that I had already taken sides with Banana. I denied it, saying I was making the call beforehand. Still, she refused to leave.
Banana spoke up and said, "I don't care if she stays - I just want to sleep."
So, I turned off the light and left the room.
In school, children follow the authority of the teacher to do assignments, even homework, even though they don't want to do it. In sports, the athletes follow the authority of the coaches, doing physically tough activities, even though it is sometimes hard, even painful, to do. In our homes, we follow the requests of our parents, because they are there to teach us lessons, even though those lessons are not always fun ones to learn.
I feel that I've lost my authority over McMonk. This is a sad thing, because without authority, I doubt she'll follow any of the hard lessons that I have for her - therefore, I've lost the ability to teach her effectively. I've noticed this in other areas of her life: her reluctance to do homework and sometimes attend school; her reluctance to be on time or attend swim practice; now, her reluctance and sometimes refusal to do as I ask her. I can see this spiraling downwards, to the point where she'll only do what she wants to do and will get used to shirking any authority.
I know she's intelligent enough to grasp big concepts like this. She and I need to have a serious talk about her disregard for authority. It is a bad path to start down.
